Editing Openai/6973e373-2b8c-800d-84b7-d7001cfc6bac (section)

=== Assistant: Here’s the argument-map for GregLiotta’s comment, using only what you’ve provided so far the pinned post is treated as … ===
Here’s the argument-map for GregLiotta’s comment, using only what you’ve provided so far (the pinned post is treated as context, and no other comments/objections have been provided yet).

==== A1. “Seasoned licensed clinician here.” ====
* This functions as an appeal to authority / credibility claim (implying his evaluation should carry extra weight).

A2. “The utter sensibility in this has its brilliance totally drowned beneath 10x too many words for a sub-reddit post.”
* Core claim: the post is substantively good but overwritten to the point that the value is obscured.

A3. “This is a NY TIMES Sunday edition article.”
* Analogy claim: the post reads like a long-form, high-word-count editorial rather than a Reddit post.

A4. “Reading on a smart phone is a NO.”
* Usability claim: the length/density makes it impractical to read on a phone.

A5. “I’ll say the first half of it is 100% spot on…”
* Accuracy claim: at least the first half is fully correct (as judged by him).

A6. “…and should be the standard model for understanding ‘AI Therapy.’”
* Normative claim: the post’s first-half framing ought to be adopted as the default/standard conceptual model.

==== Because no other comments or counterarguments have been provided yet, none of Greg’s claims are presently being questioned by a separate standing objection. ====

✅ Currently unquestioned (so far): A1, A2, A3, A4, A5, A6
⚠️ Currently in question: (none yet)
🔥 Contested both ways: (none yet)

==== Just to make the mechanism explicit (so you can see what I’ll be tracking as the thread grows): ====
* If someone replies, “It’s not too long; Reddit can handle long posts,” that would challenge A2/A3/A4.
* If someone replies, “The first half is wrong / misleading,” that would challenge A5.
* If someone replies, “This shouldn’t be the standard model,” that would challenge A6.

And if those objections themselves go unanswered, then A2–A6 would become currently in question.

Send the next comment in the thread whenever you’re ready.