Editing Openai/69434f20-ed90-800d-ab60-60312c9de3dd (section)

===== Loctarjay =====
* Logic & structure: Systematically dismantles each claim by isolating relevance, scope, and missing variables.
* Falsifiability: Correctly points out that bans, profits, Discords, and tech advancement do not quantify unique cheaters.
* Evidence handling: Separates existence of cheating from prevalence claims with consistent precision.
* Fallacy identification: Accurately calls out repeated strawmen and misrepresentation.

Net effect: Strengthens credibility through disciplined argument control and refusal to accept non-quantifying evidence.

Captain Blue
* Logic issues: Continues conflating correlated facts with prevalence conclusions.
* Argumentative flaws: Repeats strawman (“hardly anyone cheats”) despite explicit denials.
* Evidence misuse: Treats anecdote, bans, and profitability as cumulative proof without causal linkage.
* Falsifiability: Claims remain unfalsifiable and threshold-free (“masses cheat”).

Net effect: Further erosion due to persistent misrepresentation and inference stacking.