Editing Openai/695bad73-ac00-8006-b1c7-1857d5770cde (section)

== gpt-5-2 ==
=== User: hi! ===
hi!

what do you know about Hemingway's quote "for whom the bells toll"?

=== Assistant: !https://www\.bells\.org/sites/default/files/why\are\bells\ringing\today\.jpghttps://www.bells.org/sites/default/files/… ===
!https://www\.bells\.org/sites/default/files/why\_are\_bells\_ringing\_today\.jpg<ref>{{cite web|title=https://www\.bells\.org/sites/default/files/why\_are\_bells\_ringing\_today\.jpg|url=https://www.bells.org/sites/default/files/why_are_bells_ringing_today.jpg|publisher=bells.org|access-date=2026-01-09}}</ref>
!https://res\.cloudinary\.com/aenetworks/image/upload/c\_fill%2Car\_2%2Cw\_3840%2Ch\_1920%2Cg\_auto/dpr\_auto/f\_auto/q\_auto%3Aeco/v1/spanish\-civil\-war\-gettyimages\-3205437?\_a=BAVAZGID0<ref>{{cite web|title=https://res\.cloudinary\.com/aenetworks/image/upload/c\_fill%2Car\_2%2Cw\_3840%2Ch\_1920%2Cg\_auto/dpr\_auto/f\_auto/q\_auto%3Aeco/v1/spanish\-civil\-war\-gettyimages\-3205437?\_a=BAVAZGID0|url=https://res.cloudinary.com/aenetworks/image/upload/c_fill%2Car_2%2Cw_3840%2Ch_1920%2Cg_auto/dpr_auto/f_auto/q_auto%3Aeco/v1/spanish-civil-war-gettyimages-3205437?_a=BAVAZGID0|publisher=res.cloudinary.com|access-date=2026-01-09}}</ref>
!https://collectionimages\.npg\.org\.uk/large/mw111844/John\-Donne\.jpg<ref>{{cite web|title=https://collectionimages\.npg\.org\.uk/large/mw111844/John\-Donne\.jpg|url=https://images.openai.com/thumbnails/url/D1_FBnicu5mZUVJSUGylr5-al1xUWVCSmqJbkpRnoJdeXJJYkpmsl5yfq5-Zm5ieWmxfaAuUsXL0S7F0Tw70S_ZIC8oODw80M_V0d0s0D8mMCvTIifcw900LSAtz8fB1TE8vs8gKrXBMLPbL1XVUKwYASM8ljw|publisher=images.openai.com|access-date=2026-01-09}}</ref>
4
The phrase “for whom the bell tolls” is older than Hemingway—and that’s precisely why he chose it.

==== Origin: John Donne (1624) ====

The line comes from a meditation by John Donne, written while he was seriously ill. In Meditation XVII, he reflects on church bells that tolled to announce a death in the community:

: “No man is an island, entire of itself…
: never send to know for whom the bell tolls;
: it tolls for thee.”

Meaning:
When someone dies, the bell is not ringing only for that person—it’s ringing for all of us. Human lives are fundamentally interconnected; any loss diminishes the whole.

This fits remarkably well with Donne’s worldview: deeply Christian, but also profoundly social and almost proto-existential.

==== Hemingway’s use ====

Hemingway took the phrase as the title of his 1940 novel
For Whom the Bell Tolls,
set during the Spanish Civil War.

In Hemingway’s hands, the bell becomes:
* a symbol of death
* a reminder of moral responsibility
* a statement about solidarity, even in a brutal, fractured world

The novel insists that no death in war is “abstract.” Every execution, every loss, tolls for humanity as a whole—even when ideologies try to reduce people to symbols.

==== Why the quote resonates so strongly ====

There are at least three layers working simultaneously:
# Existential – You cannot detach yourself from the fate of others.
# Ethical – Indifference is a form of moral failure.
# Political – Wars are not distant events; they implicate everyone, even spectators.

This is one of the rare literary phrases that condenses an entire worldview into a single image.

==== A small but important clarification ====

Hemingway did not invent the quote, and he never presented it as his own. He expected educated readers to recognize Donne—and to feel the weight of a 300-year-old moral insight crashing into a 20th-century war.

That collision between old metaphysics and modern violence is exactly the point.

If you’d like, we can:
* unpack how this idea connects to modern networked societies,
* compare it with Camus or Hannah Arendt,
* or look at how the phrase has been emptied or distorted by pop culture.

Just tell me where you’d like to take it.